如何反驳西方对中国的各种无端指责

美国政客对中国提出种种血口喷人的指责。

这些政客大多律师出身，玩空口无凭的诡辩是他们的基本功和看家花活儿。

这些指责本来不值一驳，但是舆论反击还是必要的。

无端指责的基本特点就是经不起细节的推敲。

针对美国政客的攻击要点，我写了一些反驳的要点，算是抛砖引玉吧。

希望大家群策群力，为前方外交战线贡献一点自己的力量，反正中国媒体指望不上。

国外媒体配合政客，无数大喇叭天天造谣不止。

中国媒体在国际上存在感极低。要么不能发声，一旦发声更加被国外网民围殴，痛打如落水狗。

和中国官媒相比，西方媒体才算纯粹的洗脑工具。西方民众被媒体欺骗，世界观严重脱离现实世界。

傲慢无法拯救西方。晚清自居“天朝上国”被痛打的历史教训，在西方上演看起来为时不远了。

l  US officials hinted on multiple occasions that you cannot trust data that come from China, even though China kept updating you. Since you cannot trust that data, you should do your own homework. But you have failed to step up the research on the virus, squandering two months bought by China's sacrifice. You keep lying to your people: no need to wear face mask, no need to lock down, no risk at all, a pandemic of flu….What is unbelievable is, you have not prepared PPEs for medical workers, that amounts to murder.

 What if China had not locked down sixty million people? How much worse the situation would have been for both China and the world? How much better the situation would have been if you have step up the preparation of medical materials and lock down cities earlier? China has acted in the best interest of the people and the world.

 What have you done about the virus after you get the gene sequence in early January? WHO is informed about the possibility on Jan 1st, and back then, there is only guessing about any potential consequence. The world is alarmed even before Chinese medical professionals knows much about it. What happened in China is in extensive coverage in all kinds of media, newspapers, TV, youtube... If you do not know it, you must go to a doctor to have your IQ checked. It is an IQ problem, not a delay problem. You wasted two months, applauding for high-rising stock market, cutting airlines with Europe, and assuming you are safe.

l  What you could have done even if China has sounded alarms earlier? You haven't done anything to help your medical workers. A lot of ventilators in your inventory do not function at all. You have failed to maintain the life-saving equipment that are supposed to be ready for use 7-24 around the clock. You should be charged in the court for manslaughter.

l  The US gets the top spot in the world ranking by preparedness for a pandemic. In the Global Health Security Index, the US is the “most prepared” nation (scoring 83.5), with the UK, the Netherlands, Australia and Canada behind. China is in 51st place, scoring 48.2. China has reported to WHO and the US in the very early stage of outbreak. Let us suppose the outbreak occurs in a certain undeveloped poverty-stricken country. In that case it is reasonable to say, that country expects help from US, not the other way around. China is far behind the US in the ability to face a public health crisis. ASK WHAT THE AMERICA CAN DO FOR CHINA, DO NOT ASK WHAT CHINA CAN DO FOR AMERICA. ASK WHAT THE AMERICA CAN DO FOR THE WORLD, DO NOT ASK WHAT THE WORLD CAN DO FOR AMERICA. You are still claiming leadership in the world. Are you suggesting the US leadership is incompetent in the crisis? 

l  No country can be fully prepared. China cannot make accurate predict on what is coming, you cannot judge things from what you see in the future. Oh, maybe you can predict, because people say virus is a biological weapon leaked from a US lab, and you have extremely high positive percentages in the states all around that P4 lab.

l  You will not do anything China teaches you to do, so now you have the consequence, and in the end, you are copycatting everything China has done. If you have done it earlier, you can save ten of thousands of lives.

l  If China discloses something that is proven false, then you call it misleading; if China discloses something that is true, you call it delay. You choose to play the blame game rather than take on the virus pandemic head-on. But blaming China distracts you from fighting the virus, and it looks like you do not care about lives. You put economy in front of the people’s life, so even though people are dying, you only see economy. Only money, money and money in your eyes. What a shame to your people!

l  5 million Chinese travelled to other provincial regions, the result is 11000 cases; only tens of thousands travelled to overseas, what you see is two million cases. Why there is a huge difference? The key is what you have accused of China: stay at home, lockdown, mandatory face masks. You have created the trouble by yourselves, and now you have to pick up the takeaways taught by China.

l  China allowed people from travelling to overseas when there is risk of infection? A lot of them are foreigners. China cannot stop people to travel back to their homeland, that will be political hostage in the eye of western politicians. What you reporters will say if China lock up all Americans in Wuhan? The mayor of Wuhan can make the decision to stop Americans from returning to New York? Definitely not.

l  Americans has carried the virus to many countries, like India and Australia. Why the US fails to keep the virus inside US to protect others? Are you intentionally delaying the response? Why do you spread the virus to the other countries? If you do not do that intentionally, why do you blame China for that? If you are holding a piece of bread, if doesn’t turn to mud if it is in holding of somebody else, and vice verse. Everybody else knows you are lying. Come up and be an adult. Do not act like a little baby.

l  The virus will go to other places anyway, it is a matter of time. China cannot stand out to confront the virus alone, sheltering all the human kind behind, even if China wants to do that. Black death, Pestis, HIV, H1N1, Spanish flu, which in fact originated in the US, all found their way to other countries. You cannot put the duty solely on China, you shall do your part to protect American people.

l  SG, HK, JP, KR have much more travelers from China than US, why they are all bettering off than US? China even doesn’t make suggestions on what shall be done, they know what is required based on their reasonable minds and past experience in handling SARS and MERS. Let us assume you are right that there is delay, but why you are performing ten times worse than Asian governments? Apparently, it is a question of competence, not delay. You have failed your people, that is why you turn to the blame game.

l  When China locked down the city of Wuhan, you accused that there is violation on human rights. Now you say China is too late to lock down the city? You cannot have both on the same time.

l  Are you killing senior Americans intentionally to solve the pension problem? You have the motivation because some high-ranking officer said expressly that the old people should die for America. Why you kill your own people?

l  If there is disinformation, it lies in the US, not anywhere else. Nobody else have tried to play down the severity of this virus, only you, the United States.

l  You removed the carrier captain, and deleted millions of video clips showing how popular he is with his soldiers. This is a massive cover-up operation. What are you trying to hide up? When the death toll reached 6000 with the total case around 270000, the US is still covering up the truth. It is a shame to the human race.

l  You cannot even determine when and where the virus comes aboard the carrier Roosevelt, which involves only 5k people. It is much harder, or an impossible mission to look back and make out where the virus has originated and how it has proliferated. Virus has no nationality; it is threat to all human beings. If you call it Chinese virus, we can also call it American virus, as we see many clues that may be associated with the COVID-19: the electronic cigarette pneumonia, the secret close-down of the P4 lab in the US, the patients treated as flu infections in late 2019, on all of which the US has fails to provide an explanation to the world. Let us be frank and generous with each other for the sake of the wellbeing of the world. Stop blame China, or we must give it back. 

l  China cannot do your work instead to serve and save your people. American people pay tax and put trust in you, and you totally mess up.

l  We did not say our handling of the virus is perfect. We are in the dark in the start. You accused repeatedly that China has held information from the public. Tell me, what kind of information we could give to the public? It may be, and may be not infectious; if it is infectious, we do not know how infectious it is (R0); we have no cure, and no effective medicine for it; we do not know whether the virus is infectious during incubation period. All these questions shall be answered, and they were answered in the later development when the people around the world had daily updates on the outbreak. China has been transparent since the very start of the unfolding of this crisis. Before the crisis, we did not know there will be a crisis. On the other hand, China has demonstrated the best practice to contain and treat the virus since the outbreak, and have have accepted the Chiese practice after two months delay. Everybody made mistakes to improve. Without China's SOP, you will suffer much more. Rather than being grateful, you are biting the hand that feeds you. Benign to all, be evil to none. You have distanced yourself from the teaching of one of your greatest presidents. Do not be so mean!